Okay - I blame ticktock over at Hornetshype for this one, but there is a conspiracy floating around on the internet today: David Stern fixed the All-Star voting so that Chris Paul would edge out Tracy McGrady.
So - let's look at the numbers. Let's start with those who were getting big boosts by Chinese fans, and what they received over the last two weeks of voting:
Yao Ming gained 750,000 more votes. Yi Jianlin gained 600,000 more votes, Devin Harris gained 600,000 more votes, Vince Carter gained 500,000 more, Tracy McGrady gained a little short of 500,000 more votes. Ron Artest gained a little short of 500,000 more. Scola gained 200,000 more. Alston gained 200,000 more. Shane Battier gained 200,000 more.
Looks to me like a half a million more chinese voters popped by and gave boosts to Yao, Yi, Vince, Devin Harris, McGrady and Ron Artest. The other three guys from Houston got other, smaller boosts in line with what they had gotten before.
Then we have Paul - who gained another 1 million votes. Guess what though? LeBron James, Tim Duncan and Dwight Howard also gained 1 million more. Wade and Kobe gained 950k. Shaq, of all people, gained 850k.
When you point out that Duncan got more votes over the last two weeks than Paul, is that shocking? Is it surprising that the same people who rank Dwight, Tim and LeBron at the top of their positions on their ballots would also put Kobe and Paul at the top of theirs? Or that 300,000 Chinese who couldn't stomach the idea of Rafer Alston's name on their ballot would pick Paul (or Kobe) to replace him?
If David Stern wanted Paul to beat McGrady, do you really think he'd have him beat McGrady by 500,000 extra votes? Really?
C'mon, people! Believe in Paul and his ability to make people outside of Utah recognize he's the best damn point guard on the planet!


15 remarkable comments post your own
ticktock6
01/23/09 01:19 PM
I'm not saying it couldn't have happened. But considering that it was ridiculous to have McGrady ahead in the first place, and it not only looked like it was still happening but looked like the gap was actually widening two weeks ago... considering that last year after McGrady made douchetastic remarks about the New Orleans ASG and also coincidentally got passed at the last second... considering that the paper ballots coming in from the NBA's smallest city weren't going to put anyone over the top... I dunno.
I believe in Chris Paul. I was one of the most enraged by sheer ludicrousness of the McGrady thing. I think everyone should believe in Chris Paul.... but there's NO reason he shouldn't have been ahead all along. It's kind of a leap for me to think the results that were trending stupidly for the last month could suddenly flip flop the other way.
Regardless, the world is a much less stupid place today, indeed.
hornetshype.com #1
Ryan Schwan
01/23/09 01:27 PM
I get your reasoning, ticktock - the results were pretty surprising. Still, when Skeets picked up your post about it, I decided to attack!
Rawr!
www.hornets247.com #2
ticktock6
01/23/09 01:31 PM
I'm always starting **** on the internet!
hornetshype.com #3
Juncti
01/23/09 01:45 PM
Or it could have also been all the sports reporters, and commentators during games mentioning the situation, and people who otherwise wouldn't have voted decided to vote. In doing so they didn't just vote for Paul, but also would vote for others like Kobe, Lebron, Duncan, ect...
Hence all those players getting nice large boosts, and Yao and McGrady only getting the chinese boost.
#4
mW
01/23/09 01:50 PM
Of course, Ryan, you are also presuming Stern didn't inflate the numbers of Shaq, Duncan, et al to cover the boost to CP. Sounds thin? Seems like I'm stretching it? That's exactly what The Man wants you to think. Think about it.
www.hornetshype.com #5
YoungFella
01/23/09 02:39 PM
It's times like these as a sportsfan that I feel somewhat excluded.
Simply put, I have never cared one iota about personal awards. Drew Brees passing record? Meaningless. CP3 for MVP? I would rather get to the WCF. David West at the All Star Game? Only cared because it symbolized the NBA rebirth of New Orleans.
I just don't have any time for worries about individual awards when my city's two professional franchises have combined (in 50 years of local play) to appear in one conference championship round, have won 1 playoff series, and have 3 combined division titles. Let's get some team bling, damnit!
#6
Scott @ WFNY
01/23/09 02:44 PM
As long as Bowen didn't make it to the second forward slot, we're all good. No doubt that CP deserved that one, fix or not.
www.waitingfornextyear.com #7
Andrea
01/23/09 03:37 PM
Chris Paul= best PG in the NBA/world
Doesn't matter how he got the start for me, but I'm not buying him passing T-Mac by that many votes in such a short period of time. It's not so impossible that he couldn't have, but I just don't believe he did. Like ticktock6 said, it really was laughable that T-Mac would be ahead of CP anyway
#8
Mo
01/23/09 05:24 PM
I can't understand why people don't seem to be taking paper ballotting into effect. The paper ballots weren't even counted until paper balloting ended on 1/11. People saw the last voting results on 1/8. You have 11 more days of online voting (ended on 1/19) after that and then you have to count the arena paper ballots. No one with a brain should've been checking off McGrady on a paper ballot. The paper ballots is where CP3 killed McGrady. Good thing China didn't get paper ballots. The paper ballots from all arenas ended on 1/11. It ended in the N.O. Arena on 1/9. The "smallest city" thing doesn't have anything to do with it. It might be surprising to some but there are people OUTSIDE of New Orleans that voted for CP3 you know? A lot of Laker fans for example listed Kobe and CP3 as their starting guards? Is L.A. a small city?
#9
stormsurge
01/23/09 05:40 PM
Im not saying it didnt happen legit. Im saying it strains credibility. Its -unlikely- he got that many votes.
www.stormsurgephoto.com #10
Mo
01/23/09 05:47 PM
I don't think it's unlikely for him to get that many votes at all. If you'd step outside of your little worlds and go to other message boards, the concensus is that CP3 is indeed the best point guard in the NBA. He's become really popular over the last year. Even a lot of Rocket fans in the United States are saying CP3 should be in over McGrady. Most people on other message boards thought CP3 should've been a starter last season too. Also, lots of sportswriters/analysts, etc. lobbied for him. Like Ryan said, do you think Stern would have CP3 beat McGrady by 500K votes? Really? LMAO! I'm glad people outside of New Orleans voted for CP3 as well.
#11
mW
01/23/09 07:04 PM
First of all, calm down Mo. Secondly, do not listen to "Mo." He's actually an alias for David Stern. On the flip side, congrats to 247 for getting traffic from the commish!
www.hornetshype.com #12
Apple
01/26/09 01:36 AM
I can't believe that the NBA faked it. That would really be stupid with all the bad publicity that they've gotten out of the referee thing they would lose all the respectiblity they've had in the past and which is now on rocky ground. I believe David Stern is too smart for that.
appleita.blogspot.com/ #13
Andrew
01/27/09 05:25 PM
Why there must be a conspiracy about every single thing? I'm sick of that. The reason why Paul and other players got so many votes compared to the voting update released on Jan. 9 is because paper ballots in NBA arenas (which ended on Jan.11) still had to be counted. So, it's not surprising Paul received so many votes. Stop talking about moronic conspiracy theories and just enjoy the games!
#14
Andrew
01/27/09 05:30 PM
Also, think about that for a second. Chinese fans helped McGrady in the online vote just because he plays for the Rockets (Yao Ming), but when it comes to paper ballots fans in China can't vote, meaning that it's not that weird that Paul beat McGrady.
#15