Okay, maybe saying he can't get no respect is a bit over the top. He was the 6th leading vote getter among rookies. Still, he deserved to be on the first team, and his whole season has been a bit ridiculous considering his talent.
The season started with him sliding all the way to the 43rd pick of the draft, behind such luminaries as Victor Claver, Sergio Llull, Wayne Ellington, and Derrick Brown. Then, after he tore up the Summer League and pre-season, he was benched by Byron Scott in favor of Morris Peterson and Devin Brown. Wait, scratch that, he wasn't just benched. He was put on the inactive list and didn't even dress. Then, when Jeff Bower took over and he got a nice 20 minutes a game, he still spent a lot of time playing behind Devin Brown and Morris Peterson.
Now the All-NBA Rookie teams have come out, and he has once again slipped out of the top tier of rookies. Out of the 29 who could vote for him, only 6 coaches felt he was one of the top five rookies in the league. (voting ignores position, so that's not an excuse) 15 apparently thought that Taj Gibson, the 9 point, 7 rebound forward in Chicago, was better.
Now - this isn't trashing Taj, because he had a fine rookie season, but Marcus Thornton carried a huge load for the Hornets. He sported the highest usage rate and scoring responsibility of any rookie not named Tyreke Evans or Brendan Jennings. Only Stephen Curry took anywhere near the number of shots Thornton and managed to beat him at True Shooting Percentage.
To top it off, Thornton posted an absolutely insane turnover rate of 6.6%. That's the best rate of any guard in the league - and for a guy who handles the ball as much as he does, it's flat out freakish. Oh, and PER-wise, he finished 9th among shooting guards, ahead of much bigger names like Vince Carter, Kevin Martin, Rip Hamilton, Stephen Jackson, Monta Ellis, OJ Mayo, and Jason Terry.
Dave Berri, of course, could probably point you to some of the primary causes for Thornton's troubles. In his book Stumbling on Wins, he addresses the fact that playing shooting guard has a negative effect on your draft position and ability to win the Rookie of the Year. He also shows that draft position has a significant impact on a players ability to win Rookie of the Year and get paid. Thornton was therefore already fighting two pretty heavy strikes against him, and maybe I should be pleased he managed the second All-NBA Rookie team.
However you cut it, though, I expect it will motivate Thornton. He told Niall before the season that he was going to take his draft position as motivation. I don't expect this will change that outlook any.
Something to look forward to next year, yes?


5 masterful comments post your own
LSUhornet
04/30/10 04:10 PM
I've been ranting about this since the news came out. I was fully prepared for DeJuan Blair to be picked ahead of Buckets for this one, and you can make a decent argument for that, even though I don't necessarily agree. However, seeing Taj Gibson received more 1st place votes than Blair and Thornton combined? I think my brain just attempted suicide. The fact that the coaches pick this thing scares me even more. I guess I should have been prepared for this. Coaches rarely show any more insight than the average fan, so per game stats and starting (because they literally had no one else) for a playoff team (in the East, big deal) is all that mattered to the men who run the teams in this league. Scary, scary stuff.
I'd really like to see someone try to justify Gibson's selection with stats, because I just tried for a few minutes and think it'd be pretty impossible. Bucket's season was much more impressive, and can you imagine the numbers that DeJuan Blair would have put up if he was put in Gibson's position? Okay, rant over. I hope Thornton averages 20+ppg next year and the Hornets are at the top of the West.
#1
ticktock6
04/30/10 04:46 PM
I'm right there with you guys. I'm not surprised, but still... You know what, though? All it means is that the majority of the league's coaches still aren't going to be prepared for Marcus Thornton next year. So, in the long run, hey, it's good!
hornetshype.com #2
HornetVan
04/30/10 04:52 PM
I agree but disagree. He shouldn't have been ROY and maybe he hasn't gotten a lot of national respect....but should we really have expected anything differently considering we lost our star player and didn't make the playoffs?
If we do well next year, everyone will get more press.
We saw little of David West the last 2 years yet he was talk of the town when we were making that playoff run
#3
420ftJesus
05/01/10 12:06 AM
I have no respect for these things. They are not meaningful.
One guy said he voted for LeBron for MVP of the League. The NBA is an association. That speaks volumes to me.
#4
Jib
05/01/10 06:48 PM
the blair thing is shocking, do starts, playoffs, or colleges really make much a difference in the eyes of people? Taj may have a justification out of defense if I had to guess but when I watched him I never noticed it. Eh, more motivation for Marcus next year though.
#5